ANDREW KLAVAN: I’m Andrew Klavan and this is the Revolting Truth.
Thomas Picketty’s new book Capital in the 21st Century has excited leftists with its call for more income redistribution. The Financial Times and others say the books’ data are suspiciously skewed but the New York Times’ columnist Paul Krugman says he’s received confirmation of Picketty’s numbers on an interplanetary communication device that you can make yourself out of ordinary tinfoil you find at home.
Today, to clarify the underlying issues, the Revolting Truth presents this helpful Q&A.
Q: What is income redistribution?
A: Income redistribution is when you go to work or start a business or make an investment — and earn money — and the government takes the money away from you and gives it to someone else.
Q: So you mean it’s stealing?
A: No, it’s income redistribution.
Q: But what if I won’t give them my money?
A: Then armed men come to your house and take it.
Q: So then it’s armed robbery?
A: No, it’s income redistribution.
Q: Well, when the men try to take my money at gunpoint, what if I call the police?
A: The men are the police.
Q: The police are robbing me at gunpoint???
A: It’s income redistribution!
Q: What if I have a gun too?
A: That would be wrong.
Q: If they’re robbing me at gunpoint, why is it wrong for me to defend myself with a gun?
A: Huh?
Q: Look, instead of taking my money away to give to other people, why not just give those other people jobs?
A: It’s because there aren’t enough jobs to go around.
Q: Why not?
A: Because people aren’t spending enough or creating enough businesses or investing enough.
Q: But that’s because you took their money away!
A: Right! That’s income redistribution!
Q: Let me get this straight. We need more income redistribution because there’s too much income redistribution?
A: Congratulations. Now you’re smarter than Thomas Picketty.
Q: That’s it. I’m buying a gun.
A: But it’s income redistribution!
Q: Pound sand, you Communist thug.
Well, I hope this handy guide has been helpful in understanding Capital in the 21st Century.
Q: Come near me again and I’ll blow your head off!
I’m Andrew Klavan with the Revolting Truth.
Doug White / August 15, 2014
Wow, what a tool. Your ignorant arguments could be taken apart by an average 5th grader. Pick up a few actual books on science and try reading them, huh? (oh BTW, books are these things with pages and lots of words printed on them, you may not have ever seen one…) Try learning a bit about Game Theory, Emergence and Statistical Analysis. Once you have even the barest grounding in how things actually work, you also might want to consider some simple logic, like exactly how much money your business would earn if it were to exist in a world without the infrastructure that all of our tax dollars paid for. I know you think that was a gift we built just for you, but newsflash, it wasn’t. A human being with a functioning brain would know that your business is likely worthless if you were to transport it to the deep jungle of Papau New Guinea. But paying a measly 25% of the profits to keep that infrastructure in place is just too much burden for you, right? Ignorant clown.
/